Eight Buckeyes shine as AP All-Americans, with four making the first team. But here's where it gets controversial... The Associated Press (AP) has named these eight Ohio State players as All-Americans for the 2025 season, with wide receiver Jeremiah Smith, defensive tackle Kayden McDonald, linebacker Arvell Reese, and safety Caleb Downs leading the way. These four were also recognized by the Walter Camp Football Foundation, bringing them one step closer to becoming consensus All-Americans. But, it's the AFCA All-American team announcement on Tuesday that could spark debate. Will these players make the cut? And this is the part most people miss... While the AP and Walter Camp have acknowledged these players' excellence, the American Football Coaches Association (AFCA), Sporting News, and Football Writers Association of America (FWAA) still have their say. With only one more first-team selection needed from these organizations, the consensus All-American status hangs in the balance. So, who will make the final cut? The pressure is on, and the debate is heating up. Will these Buckeyes players be recognized as the best of the best? Stay tuned, as the consensus All-American selections will be announced on Thursday, leaving us all wondering who will be crowned champions.
